The pact was sealed with a double pinky-swear, the most sacred of all 10-year-old oaths. At precisely 11:47 PM, when the house had settled into the deep, rumbling snores of their father, Maya and Lily would execute Operation Starfall.
Maya, the instigator, was already dressed, her worn sneakers tied in a double-knot. She was the twin of action, of scraped knees and grand, half-baked ideas. Lily, tucked under her daisy-print duvet, was the strategist. She had mapped the creaky floorboards between their room and the back door with the precision of a military general.
“You hear that?” Maya whispered across the two feet of darkness separating their beds.
Lily held her breath. A floorboard downstairs groaned as the house settled. “That’s just the house breathing. Dad’s out cold. Go-time.”
They moved like shadows, a synchronized dance of practiced stealth. Down the stairs, pausing on the third and seventh steps, through the kitchen, and finally, the click of the backdoor latch sounded like a thunderclap in the silent house.
Outside, the cool August air was a sweet relief. The scent of cut grass and their mother’s night-blooming jasmine filled their lungs. They crept to the center of the lawn, their matching flannel pajama pants growing damp with dew, and lay back.
“See?” Maya breathed, pointing a finger at the inky canvas above. “The Perseids. Mom said it would be like the sky was crying diamonds.”
And it was. Tiny, brilliant streaks of light tore across the velvet blackness, and for a few minutes, the girls forgot they were on a covert mission. They were just two small people watching a cosmic spectacle.
It was Lily who saw it first. “What’s that one?” she murmured, her voice tight.
Maya followed her gaze. One of the ‘stars’ wasn’t streaking. It was growing. A pinprick of light expanded steadily, silently, into a disc. It wasn’t falling; it was descending. It had no fire, no trail, just a soft, internal luminescence like a captured moonbeam.
Panic, cold and sharp, pricked Maya’s skin. “That’s not a meteor.”
The silent disc swelled until it was the size of a car, hovering just above the cul-de-sac at the end of their street. A silence descended that was deeper than normal night-silence. The crickets stopped chirping. The wind held its breath. The object was a perfect, seamless teardrop of what looked like polished obsidian, drinking in the moonlight.
With a hum so low it was felt more in their chests than heard with their ears, three slender legs telescoped from its underbelly and touched down on the asphalt with impossible gentleness. A ramp, looking less like metal and more like solidified smoke, unfurled to the ground.
The girls were frozen, two statues in the damp grass, their grand adventure having curdled into terrifying, unbelievable reality.
A figure appeared at the top of the ramp. It was silhouetted, humanoid. And then it stepped into the glow of the streetlight.
He was wearing a beige cardigan over a plaid shirt. He adjusted his glasses, patted his pockets as if checking for his keys, and then walked down the ramp.
It was Mr. Thomas from next door.
Mr. Thomas, who grew prize-winning petunias. Mr. Thomas, who had once helped their dad fish a frisbee off his roof. Mr. Thomas, who always gave them the full-sized candy bars on Halloween.
He reached the sidewalk, turned, and gave the silent craft a small, familiar wave, the kind you’d give a departing taxi. The ramp retracted, the legs folded, and the ship lifted as silently as it had arrived. It shrank back into a pinprick of light and then vanished among the real stars.
Mr. Thomas walked up his own driveway, unlocked his front door, and disappeared inside. A moment later, the porch light flicked off. The crickets, as if given an all-clear signal, resumed their nightly chorus.
Maya and Lily didn’t speak. They scrambled to their feet and sprinted, a wild, four-legged creature of panic, back to the house, fumbling with the lock, and bolting it behind them. They didn’t stop until they were both under Lily’s duvet, a tangle of limbs and gasping breaths.
“Did you see…?” Maya started.
“…his cardigan?” Lily finished.
They stared at each other, their identical brown eyes wide with shared insanity.
“We can’t tell Mom and Dad,” Maya said, the first rule of their dilemma snapping into focus. “We’d be grounded until we’re thirty.”
“And they wouldn’t believe us anyway,” Lily added, her planner’s brain already kicking into gear, pushing past the sheer terror. “They’d think we ate too much ice cream and had a weird dream.”
“But he’s an alien!” Maya whisper-shouted, punching her pillow. “Mr. Thomas is an ALIEN! He just got dropped off! Like it was an intergalactic Uber!”
“Okay. Okay.” Lily took a deep, shaky breath. “So, we can’t tell the High Command.” That was their code for their parents. “That means we need proof. Irrefutable proof. Something we can get without them knowing.”
They sat up, the duvet pooled around them. The moon cast a silver rectangle on their bedroom floor. The mission had changed. Operation Starfall was over. Operation Alien-Hunter had begun.
“How do you prove someone’s an alien?” Maya wondered.
“In the movies, they always have something weird,” Lily reasoned. “Like, they can’t eat salt, or they glow in the dark, or they talk to squirrels.”
“Mr. Thomas salted his driveway last winter,” Maya countered. “And I’ve never seen him glow. He does talk to his petunias, though. A lot.”
“That’s not enough,” Lily said, gnawing on her thumbnail. “We need evidence. We need to get inside his house.”
“No way!” Maya’s eyes widened. “That’s breaking and entering! We need a plan that doesn’t end with us in juvie.”
For the next hour, they brainstormed in hushed, frantic tones.
The Plan – Version 1.0
Phase 1: Surveillance. Use Dad’s bird-watching binoculars to observe Mr. Thomas from their upstairs window. Look for any… alien-y behavior. Does he float? Does he recharge himself by plugging his finger into a socket?
Phase 2: The Lure. The classic ‘lost ball’ gambit. They would ‘accidentally’ throw their kickball into his prize-winning petunia bed. This would force an interaction.
Phase 3: The Test. This was Lily’s stroke of genius. During the interaction, they needed a test that only a human could pass. Not a test of knowledge, but of humanity. “I’ve got it,” Lily whispered, her eyes gleaming. “We’ll ask him a ‘would you rather’ question. A completely illogical, human one.” Maya looked confused. “Like what?” “Like, ‘Mr. Thomas, would you rather have hands for feet or feet for hands?’” Lily explained. “A human would laugh or say ‘eww’ or pick one for a funny reason. An alien, a logical being, would try to analyze it. He’d calculate the pros and cons of manual dexterity versus ambulatory efficiency. He wouldn’t get the silliness. That’s our tell.”
It was perfect. It was ridiculous. It was a plan only two 10-year-olds could concoct.
The next morning, armed with binoculars and a bright red kickball, they watched from their window as Mr. Thomas kneeled in his garden, meticulously weeding. He looked exactly the same. Same cardigan, same gentle smile as he patted the soil around a flower.
“Okay,” Maya breathed, holding the ball. “Time to engage the potential extraterrestrial.”
They trotted outside, staged a clumsy game of catch, and with a theatrical “Oops!” from Maya, the red ball sailed in a perfect arc over the fence, landing squarely in the middle of the purple petunias.
They approached the fence. “Mr. Thomas?” Lily called out, her voice a little squeakier than usual.
He looked up, shielding his eyes from the sun. “Well hello, girls. Another rogue frisbee?” he chuckled.
“A kickball this time,” Maya said, trying to look sheepish.
He smiled, a kindly, crinkly-eyed smile. “No harm done.” He gently picked his way through the flowers, retrieved the ball, and walked over to the fence. He was so… normal. For a moment, they both thought they must have dreamed it all.
He handed the ball to Maya. This was it.
“Mr. Thomas?” Lily said, her voice steady. “Can we ask you a question?”
“Of course, Lily.”
She took a deep breath. “Would you rather have spaghetti for hair or sneeze cheese?”
Mr. Thomas blinked. He looked at Lily, then at Maya. His kindly smile didn’t falter, but his eyes took on a distant, analytical quality. He tilted his head.
“An interesting query,” he said, his voice thoughtful. “Spaghetti hair would present significant logistical challenges. Maintenance, for one. The constant risk of attracting vermin. And the social implications… However, the nutritional benefits cannot be ignored, providing a constant source of carbohydrates.”
He paused, stroking his chin.
“Conversely, sneezing cheese… What kind of cheese? A soft brie would be less problematic than a sharp, crumbly cheddar. Is the volume of the sneeze proportionate to a standard human sneeze? The protein content would be beneficial, but the unpredictability and potential for dairy-based projectiles in a social setting is a considerable drawback.”
He looked at them, his expression utterly serious. “After weighing the variables, I believe spaghetti hair, while inconvenient, offers a more sustainable, long-term advantage. An excellent thought experiment, girls.”
He gave them another pleasant nod, turned, and went back to his petunias.
Maya and Lily stood frozen, the red ball clutched in Maya’s hands. They looked at each other. They didn’t need to see him glow. They didn’t need to find a laser gun in his shed.
They had their proof.
They backed away from the fence slowly, went into their house, and straight up to their room. Lily took out a notebook and a pen. At the top of the first page, she wrote in big, block letters: THE THOMAS FILES.
Their quiet suburban street was no longer boring. It was the edge of the galaxy. And they were its sole, sworn protectors. The High Command (Parents) would never know.

Leave a comment